The following is an email response dated June 27, 2015 to Jennifer Miller, a member of our stake, who shared concerns about women in the Church that she felt were serious enough to become totally inactive.
Hello, Jennifer…
Thank you for your email and for your sincere quest to get answers. We would be happy to meet with you, if you choose. Your questions are never onerous or inappropriate. We love you, your family and want to be as forthcoming and helpful as possible (with what we know). Please know of our own personal disappointment that we have not been able to answer your questions to your satisfaction.
I appreciated very much President Christiansen’s email and his attempt to get answers to your questions from Elder Holland (you would have been proud of him!). I don’t know that I can add much to what he has shared. It was very gratifying to hear Elder Holland, in the meeting referenced, be so candid and acknowledging that we don’t have all the answers. I got the sense the Brethren are very concerned about the questions you raise and are doing their very best to address them…to sort out the doctrine from the tradition. Because some of these policies (or “just the way we do things”) have been in place for so long, this will obviously take time.
After the meeting with Elder Holland, Vivienne and I had the unexpected privilege of sitting next to Elder Holland during dinner. He shared with me that the Church has created a new committee, called the Member Concerns Committee. I think he said he chairs that committee. I remember him saying this committee is mostly addressing some of the questions you raise…the women’s role in the Church, specifically leadership roles. He confirmed that it was this new committee that recommended the noticeable changes made recently: women offering prayers in General Conference; women auxiliary leaders sitting among the Brethren during conference and not with the wives off to the side; the Women’s Session becoming the official "first session" of General Conference (note it’s now the first talks published in the May/Nov Ensign). He said these changes were a kind of a “why didn’t we think of them before?” They were just oversights, so the speaking up by concerned women, like you, have not gone unrecognized or unappreciated.
I think your questions about auditors and Sunday School presidencies are valid. It was nice to hear Elder Holland suggest they’re still working on those issues. I’m sure they’re a bit more complicated simply because placing women in those positions, while not doctrinally prohibited, could create situations of a man and a woman working so closely side-by-side to lead to inappropriate relations. I think that’s why I suspect you’ll never see a man called as a counselor in a Primary presidency. I suppose, for some, this is a stupid reason to keep women from serving as auditors or in a SS presidency. “Are we so hormone-driven that we can’t keep our thoughts and hands to ourselves when in a meeting between a man and a woman?” But from the Brethren’s point of view, I could see why they would go to great lengths to avoid being the cause of such a problem. “We have enough break-up of families without us helping to create them.”
As you know, this “problem” arises when a bishop, or other priesthood leader, conducts an interview alone with a woman. As indication of how concerned the Brethren are about this potential situation, bishops are cautioned regularly to make sure some one else is in the building during such an interview; have a table or desk between the two of you; do not ask questions about intimacy or intimate practices, etc.
I share this so you’ll know that I feel the Brethren really are trying to address these issues. Again, some of these matters have been tradition for so long that it takes time to unravel the traditions and make sure they don’t contradict doctrine or prophetic “policies” established years before. From our stand point, these matters may appear like no-brainers, but when making decisions at the general church level, you can imagine the number who have to sign off on such policy changes. In fact, no policies are changed until there is total unanimity among the First Presidency and the Twelve. If there is discord among them, they wait for the Spirit to soften hearts and everyone becomes “settled” before moving forward.
As for your question about the priesthood, I personally don’t feel it makes a man more inclined to receiving revelation than women. A priesthood holder is supposed to seek revelation for his circle or level of stewardship, but so is a woman. I believe it’s mostly to bring order into His church, to some extent what Herb suggested. I’m confident there is more to the “why” it rests solely with males that we will learn some day and I’m confident it will make sense when we do find out. (No, I don’t know when that will be, but maybe it’s a trial of our faith that will be addressed at the Judgment; probably at the same time we learn the real “why” behind plural marriage and other doctrines and practices that have proven to be troubling or even divisive.)
Jennifer, you know how much we love you and your family and it would break our hearts if you chose to go completely inactive. We plead with you to be patient. Maybe you feel your patience has been exhausted. But I see these recent “signs” as solid indicators that the Brethren are listening and trying to address them as best and as quickly as possible.
Please consider reviewing again Elder Holland’s talk in the April 2013 Conference where he conceded there are things we don’t have answers for. But he gave this wonderful, relevant counsel: “…when those moments come and issues surface, the resolution of which is not immediately forthcoming, hold fast to what you already know and stand strong until additional knowledge comes…Sometimes we act as if an honest declaration of doubt is a higher manifestation of moral courage than is an honest declaration of faith. It is not!…Be as candid about your questions as you need to be; life is full of them on one subject or another. But if you and your family want to be healed, don’t let those questions stand in the way of faith working its miracle.”
I hope this is helpful. If you still want to meet, please let us know and we’ll be happy to schedule a time.
President Lewis